If there’s one thing most people can seemingly agree on, it’s that a hearty bowl of pasta is always good choice. Heavy with Italian tradition, Chicago is home to some of the country’s best red sauce restaurants. From timeless classics, such as spaghetti and meatballs and chicken Vesuvio, to dishes featuring luxe ingredients like truffles, there’s a ton of variety to be had. Many restaurants have histories spanning decades while others are relative newcomers. The one thing they all have in common: Cooking that would make nonna proud. New additions to the list include Tuscan-style favorite Topo Gigio, longstanding Cicero institution Freddy’s Pizza, and Avondale darling Pisolino.
Read More
The 20 Essential Italian Restaurants in Chicago
Chianti and carbs galore
1. Bar Roma
Chicago, IL 60640
The meatball gets full attention at this cozy Andersonville spot. Housed inside a building that’s more than 100 years old, Bar Roma specializes in polpette. The signature dish is available in several varieties: Beef, pork, chicken, or Impossible “meat.” Order them alongside one of the house-made pastas and save room for tiramisu.
2. Pisolino
Chicago, IL 60618
Pisolino is the type of restaurant every neighborhood needs. It’s a come as you are spot with a deep wine list, criminally underrated thin-crust pizza, and delicious pastas from chef James De Marte. The orecchiette with spicy sausage is a crowd pleaser. It’s a place with serious cooking that doesn’t take itself seriously, which is why the menu jokes about not being able to accommodate garlic allergies “due to the nature of our cooking.”
Also Featured in:
3. Sapori Trattoria
Chicago, IL 60614
Upscale yet comfortable, Sapori Trattoria is a restaurant for any occasion. The menu is loaded with pastas — be sure to try the seafood linguine or lobster-stuffed ravioli — as well as specialties such as a six-hour-braised osso buco. Those looking for a date-night atmosphere should come on Tuesdays when there’s live jazz musicians serenading the dining room.
4. Riccardo Trattoria
Chicago, IL 60614
Hailing from a family with a rich restaurant pedigree, chef and owner Riccardo Michi delivers some of the finest Tuscan food on the North Side. Diners pack the homey dining room every night to try daily specials and crowd pleasers including lobster-and-crab ravioli, lasagna, and luscious panna cotta. Don’t be afraid to try the trippa alla Fiorentina, either. The honeycomb tripe braised with veggies and tomato sauce is a memorable combination.
5. Osteria Langhe
Chicago, IL 60647
Delve into the flavors of northern Italy at this acclaimed Logan Square restaurant. Focusing on the Piedmont region, Osteria Langhe goes beyond tried-and-true dishes and instead serves hand-pinched plin, tripe and tongue stew, and prosciutto-wrapped rabbit loin. After dinner, do as the Italians do and sip some amaro.
6. Topo Gigio
Chicago, IL 60610
With an alluring patio and traditional Tuscan-style plates, Topo Gigio embodies the spirit of a good neighborhood trattoria. The Old Town restaurant churns out dependable versions of baked clams, eggplant parm, veal chops, and tiramisu. In the colder months, heaters keep the outdoor dining area warm and comfortable.
7. Nico Osteria
Chicago, IL 60611
Nico Osteria, the sleek restaurant inside the Thompson Chicago hotel, doesn’t have a long, storied history like other places on this last but the food leaves a lasting impression nonetheless. Pristine crudo, lobster spaghetti, and deconstructed tiramisu are just a few of the contemporary bites that await. Short on time? No problem. The bar area, dubbed Salone Nico, is a perfect place to unwind with a stiff drink and light snack.
8. Spiaggia
Chicago, IL 60611
Tony Mantuano’s Michelin-starred-restaurant on the Mag Mile is the gold standard for Italian fine dining in Chicago. The beautiful space, which was remodeled in 2014, sets the scene for decadent offerings that include gnocchi showered in white truffle, dry-aged bistecca alla fiorentina, and caviar with burrata. There are also five- or eight-course tasting menus. For a more casual experience, sister restaurant Cafe Spiaggia doles out equally refined pastas and dishes.
9. La Scarola
Chicago, IL 60654
Boasting red sauce that would make nonna proud and a small dining room covered in celebrity photos, La Scarola is an inviting haven for simple but satisfying fare. Bring companions along to share large portions of penne alla vodka, escarole and beans, veal chops, eggplant parm, pasta e fagioli, and more. It’s the Italian way.
Also Featured in:
10. Piccolo Sogno
Chicago, IL 60642
Escape the bustle of the city at this popular River West spot and enjoy an intimate evening filled with fresh, rustic cuisine and an extensive all-Italian wine list. The “little dream” restaurant, the restaurant name’s translation, of Tony Priolo and Ciro Longobardo comforts diners with first-rate items like seafood spaghetti nero, pappardelle in wild boar ragu, braised beef short ribs, and wood-fired pizzas. In the summertime, the lush garden patio is among the best for al fresco dining.
11. Coco Pazzo
Chicago, IL 60654
Places frequently open and shutter in River North but Coco Pazzo has proven itself a cornerstone of the neighborhood. Situated in a loft space with floor-to-ceiling curtains, it was at the forefront of the Tuscan-inspired cooking movement that rose to prominence in the ‘90s. Today, it’s still a great spot for fare such as potato gnocchetti with Asiago fondue, spicy seafood stew, and wood-roasted whole branzino. Meat lovers can share Florence’s famed bistecca, a beefy 40 oz. porterhouse for two that’s sliced tableside.
12. Formento's
Chicago, IL 60607
Old-school Italian gets the spotlight at B. Hospitality Co.’s West Loop restaurant. The interior sports a classic look — big leather booths, white tablecloths — while the kitchen executes Italian-American staples with reverence. Whether or not guests grew up in red sauce households, diners can try dishes such as canestri in pork neck gravy, bucatini carbonara, and bone-in veal parmesan.
13. Monteverde
Chicago, IL 60607
Top Chef and Spiaggia vet Sarah Grueneberg presents a modern take on regional Italian flavors with an emphasis on freshly made pastas. Her restaurant’s lauded lineup features hits such as “cacio whey pepe” and a family-sized serving of ragu teeming with fusilli, sausage, meatballs, and pork shank. Grueneberg’s efforts were rewarded in 2017 when she took home the James Beard Award for Best Chef in the Great Lakes region.
14. Italian Village
Chicago, IL 60603
One of the city’s oldest institutions is comprised of three separate restaurants. On the top floor, the Village first introduced Chicagoans to regional specialties, such as cannelloni, saltimbocca, and fettuccini alfredo, back in 1927. It takes place in a dining room designed to feel like an idyllic Italian village. Downstairs on the ground floor, theatrical-themed Vivere offers a more upscale setting, while La Cantina in the basement is modeled after a cozy wine cellar.
15. Tufano's Vernon Park Tap
Chicago, IL 60607
Guests don’t have to be Italian to feel like family at this longstanding eatery. Owned by the DiBuono family since 1931, little has changed at Tufano’s over the decades. Loyal customers stop in every night for hearty red sauce dishes and favorites like eggplant parm and lemon chicken Vesuvio. Other old-school touches include chalkboard menus and a cash-only policy. The James Beard Foundation honored the restaurant as one of “America’s Classics” in 2008.
16. The Rosebud
Chicago, IL 60607
When Chicagoans think of Little Italy, the Rosebud quickly springs to mind. The Taylor Street mainstay launched an Italian empire by drawing in folks with generous portions and a convivial atmosphere. Come for the history, stay for spaghetti and meatballs, baked clams, chicken Vesuvio, and tiramisu.
17. Davanti Enoteca
Chicago, IL 60607
There are plenty of options on Taylor Street for a good Italian meal but people flock to Davanti Enoteca for a reason. The rustic menu features shared plates while the walls are lined with bottles, mimicking the feel of dining in a wine cellar. Highlights include focaccia, whipped ricotta with honeycomb, cacio e pepe, and an outstanding burger topped with bacon jam and cheese curds.
18. Freddy's Pizza
Cicero, IL 60804
Though the name suggests that pizzas are the main attraction, Freddy’s slings much more than just pies. Cicero residents line up at owner Giuseppe Quercia’s grocer and deli, where they can stock up on Italian meats and an assortment of other goods. Customers can also order food at the counter and grab a seat; the menu features thick Sicilian-style pizzas, house-made meatballs, pastas, calzones, gelato, Italian ice, and more. It’s cash only, so bring some bills.
Also Featured in:
19. Bacchanalia
Chicago, IL 60608
Head to the Heart of Italy for this family-run operation that’s been around for four decades. Touting recipes from the “old country,” Bacchanalia produces noteworthy renditions of linguine with clams, breaded pork tenderloin, veal scallopini, gorgonzola gnocchi, and more. To finish, pistachio cannoli are a must.
20. Bruna's Ristorante
Chicago, IL 60608
A restaurant that has lasted for more than 80 years must be doing a lot right. That’s the case at Bruna’s, a South Side stalwart as charming as it is delicious. The porcini ravioli, veal limone, and tiramisu are all favorites and on Sundays, Bella Bruna’s original roast chicken recipe brings in all the regulars.
Also Featured in:
Loading comments...