clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
M Burger
M Burger
Facebook

10 Great & Gooey Grilled Cheeses to Try in Chicago, Mapped

Tomato soup is optional, but recommended

View as Map
M Burger
| Facebook

Some of the best things in life are also the simplest. That's why the grilled cheese sandwich is a classic that's universally-loved by kids and adults alike. Because no matter the age, there's always comfort to be found in a bite of gooey melted cheese.

While your mom might've made grilled cheese using Kraft singles and Wonder Bread, Chicago restaurants are definitely stepping it up a notch. Chefs are elevating the sandwich game and showing off their creativity with footlong sandwiches, deep-fried wonders and more. It's safe to say that these creations will open your taste buds up to a new flavors when it comes to grilled cheese.

From the ritzy 3 Arts Club Cafe to unexpected joints such as BIG & little's and Edzo's, grilled cheese is no longer just a sidenote on menus. It's having its moment so check out the map below for 10 fantastic spots to get cheesy.

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

3 Arts Club Cafe

Copy Link

Luxury and decadence extend beyond the posh setting at Brendan Sodikoff's popular cafe inside Restoration Hardware. It’s also reflected in the food. Case in point: the grilled cheese, made with cheddar and truffle butter, is a fancy version that’ll leave you feeling like royalty.

BIG & little's

Copy Link

Patrons usually head to BIG & little’s in River North and Wicker Park for the fantastic fish tacos and burgers, but hidden away in the depths of the menu is a jaw-dropping deep fried grilled cheese. No fancy techniques here—just an old fashioned grilled cheese, with American or Swiss, thrown into the fryer to produce a golden, crispy ball of awesomeness. Not for the faint of heart, or anyone with high cholesterol.

Huge Galdones

Cheesie's Pub & Grub

Copy Link

Few things in life feel better than demolishing a grilled cheese sandwich after an evening on the town. That’s why Cheesie’s, which is open until 5 a.m. on the weekend, is perhaps the ultimate late-night comfort spot. Feed that hunger with basics like The Classic (Merkt’s cheddar, American cheese, tomatoes, ham and bacon), or enjoy intriguing creations such as The Mac (Merkt’s cheddar, American cheese, housemade mac and cheese) and The Tradicion (Chihuahua cheese, jalapenos and chorizo). Cheesie's also has locations in Evanston and Wicker Park, and a food truck.

Edzo's Burger Shop

Copy Link

It takes a lot to say no to one of the juicy, tantalizing burgers at Edzo’s, but the surprising inside-out grilled cheese makes a compelling case. Owner Eddie Lakin raises the bar by putting shredded parmesan on the outside of the sandwich and griddling it. The result is a savory layer that adds another dimension to the simple-yet-irresistible classic.

Gayle's Best Ever Grilled Cheese

Copy Link

It’s not bragging if you can back it up, and Gayle Voss can definitely stake a claim to the best grilled cheese in Chicago. The sandwich maker was a longtime fixture at local farmers markets before opening her own storefront at Block 37 last year. Workers in the Loop have access to a number of different creations, ranging from the Southport (butterkase and smoked onion marmalade) to seasonal specials like The Abreo (cheddar, honey crisp apples and bacon onion jam) and The Sebastian (butterkase and lobster).

Hopleaf Bar

Copy Link

Beer, mussels and frites are always requisites at Andersonville’s lauded beer bar but the CB&J sandwich shouldn’t be overlooked either. Ordinary becomes extraordinary thanks to cashew butter, raclette cheese and fig jam that provides a hint of sweetness. It’s served with Stilton mac for an unbeatable duo of cheesiness.

Jerry's

Copy Link

If there’s a sandwich you fantasize about, they can probably build it at Jerry’s. The sandwich specialist offers dozens of possibilities; the only limit is your imagination. Among the various grilled cheese options, the "Nutball" is a standout. The grand prize winner at this year’s Time Out Chicago Meltdown Fest is a satisfying blend of Swiss, provolone and cheddar that’s enhanced with cashew butter, applewood bacon, and mango-chipotle chutney dip.

M Burger

Copy Link

Although the Chicago burger chain keeps things relatively simple on its regular menu, fans in the know can order secret items for more variety. One of these unadvertised specials is a “grown-up” grilled cheese with avocado and tomato, but the real heartstopper is the option to order any sandwich “Roman-style.” Doing so replaces the bun with two grilled cheeses. Yes, you read that right. No, you probably don’t want to know the nutritional value.

The Fat Shallot

Copy Link

One of the city’s finest food trucks has found a permanent home inside Revival Food Hall in the Loop. Now, visitors to downtown’s hottest lunch spot can nosh on Fat Shallot favorites like the grilled cheese, which packs ooey gooey melted muenster cheese with sautéed spinach and caramelized onions.

The Scout Waterhouse + Kitchen

Copy Link

There can never be too much of a good thing, especially when it comes to grilled cheese. The Scout’s signature footlong sandwiches are impressive sights to behold and devour. They’re available in variations like The “Wolff” (double smoked bacon, jalapenos) and come served with tomato basil dip so that you can relive those childhood memories.

3 Arts Club Cafe

Luxury and decadence extend beyond the posh setting at Brendan Sodikoff's popular cafe inside Restoration Hardware. It’s also reflected in the food. Case in point: the grilled cheese, made with cheddar and truffle butter, is a fancy version that’ll leave you feeling like royalty.

BIG & little's

Huge Galdones

Patrons usually head to BIG & little’s in River North and Wicker Park for the fantastic fish tacos and burgers, but hidden away in the depths of the menu is a jaw-dropping deep fried grilled cheese. No fancy techniques here—just an old fashioned grilled cheese, with American or Swiss, thrown into the fryer to produce a golden, crispy ball of awesomeness. Not for the faint of heart, or anyone with high cholesterol.

Huge Galdones

Cheesie's Pub & Grub

Few things in life feel better than demolishing a grilled cheese sandwich after an evening on the town. That’s why Cheesie’s, which is open until 5 a.m. on the weekend, is perhaps the ultimate late-night comfort spot. Feed that hunger with basics like The Classic (Merkt’s cheddar, American cheese, tomatoes, ham and bacon), or enjoy intriguing creations such as The Mac (Merkt’s cheddar, American cheese, housemade mac and cheese) and The Tradicion (Chihuahua cheese, jalapenos and chorizo). Cheesie's also has locations in Evanston and Wicker Park, and a food truck.

Edzo's Burger Shop

It takes a lot to say no to one of the juicy, tantalizing burgers at Edzo’s, but the surprising inside-out grilled cheese makes a compelling case. Owner Eddie Lakin raises the bar by putting shredded parmesan on the outside of the sandwich and griddling it. The result is a savory layer that adds another dimension to the simple-yet-irresistible classic.

Gayle's Best Ever Grilled Cheese

It’s not bragging if you can back it up, and Gayle Voss can definitely stake a claim to the best grilled cheese in Chicago. The sandwich maker was a longtime fixture at local farmers markets before opening her own storefront at Block 37 last year. Workers in the Loop have access to a number of different creations, ranging from the Southport (butterkase and smoked onion marmalade) to seasonal specials like The Abreo (cheddar, honey crisp apples and bacon onion jam) and The Sebastian (butterkase and lobster).

Hopleaf Bar

Beer, mussels and frites are always requisites at Andersonville’s lauded beer bar but the CB&J sandwich shouldn’t be overlooked either. Ordinary becomes extraordinary thanks to cashew butter, raclette cheese and fig jam that provides a hint of sweetness. It’s served with Stilton mac for an unbeatable duo of cheesiness.

Jerry's

If there’s a sandwich you fantasize about, they can probably build it at Jerry’s. The sandwich specialist offers dozens of possibilities; the only limit is your imagination. Among the various grilled cheese options, the "Nutball" is a standout. The grand prize winner at this year’s Time Out Chicago Meltdown Fest is a satisfying blend of Swiss, provolone and cheddar that’s enhanced with cashew butter, applewood bacon, and mango-chipotle chutney dip.

M Burger

Although the Chicago burger chain keeps things relatively simple on its regular menu, fans in the know can order secret items for more variety. One of these unadvertised specials is a “grown-up” grilled cheese with avocado and tomato, but the real heartstopper is the option to order any sandwich “Roman-style.” Doing so replaces the bun with two grilled cheeses. Yes, you read that right. No, you probably don’t want to know the nutritional value.

The Fat Shallot

One of the city’s finest food trucks has found a permanent home inside Revival Food Hall in the Loop. Now, visitors to downtown’s hottest lunch spot can nosh on Fat Shallot favorites like the grilled cheese, which packs ooey gooey melted muenster cheese with sautéed spinach and caramelized onions.

The Scout Waterhouse + Kitchen

There can never be too much of a good thing, especially when it comes to grilled cheese. The Scout’s signature footlong sandwiches are impressive sights to behold and devour. They’re available in variations like The “Wolff” (double smoked bacon, jalapenos) and come served with tomato basil dip so that you can relive those childhood memories.

Related Maps