clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
A glorious NY-style pepperoni pizza.
Paulie Gee’s has opened a Wicker Park slice shop.
Garrett Sweet/Eater Chicago

Filed under:

Find Majestic New York-Style Pizza Slices in Wicker Park From Paulie Gee’s

The second Chicago location of the New York import is different from the Logan Square original

If you buy something from an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

Ashok Selvam is the editor of Eater Chicago and a native Chicagoan armed with more than two decades of award-winning journalism. Now covering the world of restaurants and food, his nut graphs are super nutty.

Some of the city’s top pizzerias are experimenting with their menus during a pandemic which has shaken consumer confidence when it comes to indoor dining. For example, Pizza Fried Chicken Ice Cream in Bridgeport shifted from thicker Sicilian-style pizzas to thin-cut tavern style, as the Tribune reports — ownership felt thin and crispy held up better after transport during the winter.

A pizza counter with pizzas.
The pizza counter at Paulie Gee’s Wicker Park will have specials like the “I’ll Pork You.”
Garrett Sweet/Eater Chicago

Over in Logan Square, Derrick Tung has been trying out new ideas for the past year at Paulie Gee’s. Not only did he install a display case to add a pickup window to his business, he also began serving New York-style pizzas which are famously durable. Paulie Gee’s New Neapolitan pies, which originated in Brooklyn, are meant to be immediately consumed out of the wood-fired oven. Serious pizza makers scoff at the notion of takeout or delivery. But seriousness gives way to survival during a pandemic.

N.Y.-style pizzas will eventually be exclusive to Wicker Park.

The pie rolls out of the oven.

Tung, who was already looking to open location that concentrated on serving slices, has recently opened a second location in Wicker Park. The slice shop also has a pickup window facing the busy North/Damen/Milwaukee intersection and focuses on New York-style pies. They’ll have a selection of 13 and toppings like sausage and pepperoni — which wasn’t available from the space’s past tenant, Bonci — are available. But chef Tony Dezutter, who is managing partner with William Ravert, also wants to experiment. One pie is called “I’ll Pork You,” and comes topped with citrus-roasted pork pineapple habanero sauce, cilantro sauce, garlic, pickled red onions, and mozzarella.

Vegans and vegetarians will find pizza options. The shop will also serve breakfast sandwiches served on a ciabatta bun with scrambled eggs, caramelized onions, and sausage. Other toppings include bacon jam. They’ll also considering offering and egg substitute to veganize the item. There’s also fried potato wedges for a complete meal on mornings from Friday through Sunday.

Breakfast sandwiches on fresh ciabatta are available Friday through Sunday.

Whole pies will be available to go, but don’t expect to find Detroit-style squares. That appears to be a Logan Square exclusive. For now, Logan Square will also serve New York style, though Tung says he’ll eventually make those pizzas only available in Wicker Park; he wants to keep his shops unique. For Wicker Park, a neighborhood that hasn’t had N.Y.-style slices since Santullo’s closed a few years ago, it’s a welcome addition to a neighborhood that counts Piece, Lou Malnati’s, Dimo’s, Knead, Happy Camper, and Craft pizza.

Chicago is a much more welcoming place for different pizza styles compared to New York. Places like Jimmy’s Pizza Cafe are praised for its tasty N.Y.-style slices. But still, Chicago has scant spots for those big and foldable slices. Thankfully, Wicker Park now has a contender. The city’s second Paulie Gee’s location is now open. Just make sure to warm up that pizza in the oven at home before enjoying. Tung insists.

Paulie Gee’s Wicker Park, (773) 661-6793, 1566 N. Damen Avenue, open 4 p.m. to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday; 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on Friday through Sunday. Online ordering for carryout via Toast and delivery via Grubhub.

Classic toppings will always be available.
Pizza in its purest form.

Paulie Gee's Wicker Park

1566 North Damen Avenue, , IL 60622 (773) 661-6793 Visit Website
Chicago Restaurant Closings

Caffe Streets in Wicker Park and a Pair of North Shore Restaurant Closures


Lincoln Park Discovers Its Soul

Coming Attractions

Chef Paul Virant Will Return to His French Roots