clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

The Early Word on Barbecue Utopia Bub City

New, 5 comments

If you buy something from an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

Bub City, the revamped River North barbecue joint operated by popular Chicago restauranteurs R.J. and Jerrod Melman and mixologist Paul McGee, has received mixed reviews since its opening over a month ago. While many customers enjoy the vibrant country music and smoked meat offerings, others are skeptical of the service and value. Here's the early word on Bub City:

The Good News: A Yelper raves about the menu: "Five words: lobster roll sweet potato fluff. I sleep a little better just knowing they exist. Also the spoon bread. Also the tater tots. Also try the stone fence. This place is the awesome food without the what-to-wear hassle. Am I a fan of country music? Well, when I'm here I am. I can't deny it: it pairs too well with everything else." [Yelp]

The Bad News: A Foursquare user isn't impressed: "Is that pulled pork or pulled fat? Yes. . This place joins a long line of Chicago BBQ places that aren't worth much." [Foursquare]

The Pork News: Blog The Ghost Guest sheds some light on the barbecued pig: "The pork was extremely tender and not smothered in sauce, which I always appreciate. You almost didn't need any sauce at all, but I had to try each of Bub City's homemade sauces. That pork certainly rivaled my other favorites at Chicago Q and Smoque." [The Ghost Guest]

The Staff News: An Eater commenter feels ransomed at the restaurant: "The food is okay at best, but the management is completely incompetent. We finished our meal, gave our server our credit card - as normal; nothing special - and because THEIR COMPUTERS WERE DOWN, IT TOOK 45 MINUTES TO PROCESS. They would not return our card, they did not offer us a drink (except water), they did not comp the meal, they kept apologizing but did nothing. It was like being held hostage. I told them to return the cards and let us go and they kept saying they "were working on it." [Eater Comments]

The Drink News: Red Eye Chicago appreciates the strong cocktails: "Likewise, the Horse's Neck (With a Kick)—a bourbon, lemon, ginger beer combo that tasted like a harder-partying dark 'n' stormy—was seriously strong. More ambitious folks around me went straight for the extensive whiskey list, organized by distillery and featuring some barrels that McGee himself selected on a trip to Kentucky. Lesson? Sip slowly—you're getting your money's worth." [REChi]

The Recommendation News: One Yelp reviewer finds the waitress inauthentic: "The food is really good. The service was so so. I like to ask them a few questions about items on the menu & she kept saying she "loved" everything I asked & how it was her favorite. How many favorites can you have? I liked the live music! When they put their regular music on tho its so loud you can even talk. Our server was ok, but not much of a personality or smiler. We will be back tho." [Yelp]

The Regular News: On Twitter @btenenbaum makes return trips: "Headed to @BubCityChi for my 6th time. I guess you could say I am a fan. Always support the buds @RJMelman @JerrodMelman" [Twitter]

The Smokey News: Blog Newman Knows Chicago rates the barbecue: "Pulled pork should be tender and full of smoke even if it's the gun smoke from the gun that slaughtered the poor little pig. For tender I give it four out of five revolvers. For smoke, well, lets just say, he was shooting blanks." [NKC]
— Ashley Mason

· All Bub City Coverage [-EChi-]
· Look Inside Bub City, Opening Tonight [-EChi-]
· Bub City [Official Website]
[Photo: Barry Brecheisen]

Bub City

435 North Clark Street, , IL 60654 (312) 610-4200 Visit Website

Bub City

435 N Clark St Chicago, IL 60654

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater Chicago newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world